Here’s a Little Tough Love

During my battle with colon cancer, I had the lovely opportunity of having a colostomy bag. Basically, my internal plumbing was rerouted to the lower left side of my belly, and I pooped in a bag. 

I was so self-conscious of it. I thought everyone could see it; worse, I thought they could smell it, and even more horrifying was the fact that I had no control over it, meaning it would fart and puff up my shirt at the worst times. (You can hear me tell that story on the Ignite Your Spark podcast.) 

This experience taught me compassion in the most visceral way. My secret suffering (no one could see, smell, or rarely hear my bag) made me realize that I, too, had no idea what someone else was dealing with. 

Compassion is defined as having sympathetic pity & concern for the sufferings or misfortunes of others.  

“Everyone is fighting a battle you know nothing about. Be kind. Always.”

While this quote is true, it suggests that compassion is never upsetting and doesn’t hurt the other person’s feelings. It’s easy-breezy, full of yoga retreats, meditations, and sunshine & rainbows. 

So what about the person who keeps repeating the same patterns of suffering over and over again? Is it possible to give them a piece of your mind, honestly, with loving-kindness, and with compassion? 

Perhaps it’s time for a bit of tough compassion. 

Dacher Keltner, Greater Good Science Center founding director, defines tough compassion as the “willingness to bear - even inflict - some discomfort in the moment to promote longer-term well-being.  If you have or have cared for children, then you’ve most likely practiced tough compassion. 

“No dessert until you finish all your vegetables.”

“Once your homework is finished, you can go play with your friends.”

Giving this type of tough compassion can ridiculously hard, especially if you’re a people pleaser. 

The key is to do your best to let the other person know that you value them even though you disagree with their behavior or statement by stating how their words or actions impact you on an emotional level. 

Husband #2 is a legal immigrant to the United States. Just like today, immigration & border control was a huge topic, and loads of hurtful racist comments were flooding the internet. 

Someone close to me reposted one of these comments causing my husband to question their true acceptance and love for him. He said to me, “Have you seen what she posted?! It’s incredibly rude, and I can’t believe she would support something like that. It makes me feel that every time she said she loved me, she was lying.”

Soft compassion would say, “I’m sure she didn’t mean it.” or “She didn’t mean you; she’s talking about people who come illegally.” Essentially brushing her comments under the rug to not cause a rift in the relationship. 

But the rift was there; the trust compromised. 

I chose tough compassion and said to this person, “Your recent post was very hurtful to us. It now has my husband questioning the honesty of the relationship. I’m sure that you didn’t mean to offend him, but I wanted you to know how those types of comments affect the people in your life.”

She felt terrible. Indeed she had not thought about how the comment would be received and the nuances of the issue. She removed the post and apologized to my husband. 

Yes, it was hard to make that phone call. Yes, there were tears and embarrassment. And the relationship was repaired. Had we said nothing in an effort not to rock the boat, the trust would have remained damaged, and resentment would have set in. 

When husband #2 and I were getting divorced, I was going the rounds with blame and shame. At a certain point, my coach at the time said, “Karey, week after week, it’s the same story, the same complaints. Do you really want to do something about this, or do you just want to complain? If you want to do the work and move through this, I’m here. If you just want to complain, then you should save your money, and we should end our time together.”

Ouch! 

She called me out on my BS with compassion. She told me clearly what she was and wasn’t willing to do. It was the kick in the pants I needed to finally dive into the work of healing and letting go.

Is there someone or something in your life that could benefit from a little tough compassion? Here are a few things to keep in mind:

  1. Be sure that you are grounded in your intention for the conversation

  2. Practice unattachment to the outcome. 

  3. Try not to use shame.

  4. Use story telling to demonstrate how the comment or behavior effects you or someone you know. 

  5. Get curious about what’s driving their thoughts or comments. 

  6. Explain how a shift in course could be a win-win for all involved.

  7. Sometimes tough compassion means leaving the conversation or situation

Tough compassion is about creating space for dialogue. Ultimately, it’s up to the person to decide if they are ready & willing to make a shift. 

I want to hear from you; have you had to use tough compassion? How did it go? 

Here’s to growing, 

Signature.png